While Panera Bread is renowned for its salads, soups, and sandwiches, the bagels hold a special place in many customers' hearts. As a child, the writer's first experiences with Panera revolved around these delightful baked goods. Her sister favored the Cinnamon Crunch variety, while she herself was partial to Asiago bagels. The honey walnut cream cheese also found favor with her mother. Though not at par with authentic NYC-style bagels, Panera’s versions serve as an excellent alternative on busy mornings when time is tight. To help you decide which ones are worth your while, a food editor tested all eight options.

Through thorough taste testing, this article provides reviews, original photos, and a definitive ranking of Panera's bagels. Whether you're looking for a quick breakfast or just curious about what makes these bagels unique, this guide will assist you in making the best choice. Read on to discover which flavors stand out and why they deserve a spot in your morning routine.

The Unique Appeal of Panera Bagels

Despite being overshadowed by Panera's other offerings, bagels have their own charm. They offer a nostalgic trip back to childhood memories for some, like the author who recalls enjoying Asiago bagels. Even though these bagels might not meet the high standards set by dedicated bagel shops or New York City establishments, they provide convenience during hectic mornings. For those seeking a reliable option without waiting long in line, Panera's bagels fulfill that need admirably.

Beyond mere nostalgia, there lies a practicality to choosing Panera bagels. When your preferred bagel shop has lines stretching out the door, these bagels become a viable substitute. Their availability ensures that even amidst a rush, one can still enjoy a warm, freshly baked treat. This section explores how Panera manages to create bagels that cater to diverse tastes, from the sweet allure of the Cinnamon Crunch to the savory notes of Asiago. Each flavor offers something distinct, ensuring there's a bagel for everyone.

An Expert's Take on Panera Bagels

To ensure you make the most informed decision, a seasoned food editor conducted an exhaustive evaluation of all eight bagel varieties available at Panera. This endeavor resulted in detailed reviews complemented by original photography, providing visual insights into each bagel's characteristics. By ranking these bagels based on taste, texture, and overall appeal, this guide aims to enhance your dining experience.

Delving deeper into the tasting process, it becomes evident that certain bagels rise above others due to specific attributes. The Cinnamon Crunch bagel captivates with its sugary crust and robust cinnamon flavor, appealing to those with a sweet tooth. Meanwhile, the Asiago bagel satisfies savory preferences with its subtle cheese undertones. Each review delves into what makes these bagels noteworthy, discussing factors such as chewiness, aroma, and pairing potential with spreads like cream cheese. This comprehensive analysis equips readers with the knowledge needed to select their ideal bagel effortlessly.