Proposed FDA Commissioner Outlines Plans for School Lunches, Mifepristone Review, and Ethics Overhaul

Mar 6, 2025 at 10:18 PM

Dr. Marty Makary, nominated by President Donald Trump to lead the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), outlined his priorities during a recent Senate confirmation hearing. If confirmed, Makary plans to scrutinize school lunch programs, review the abortion pill mifepristone, and reassess the agency's advisory committees. The hearing also touched on the controversial cancellation of a vaccine advisory committee meeting and the need to ensure ethical standards within the FDA. Makary emphasized the importance of addressing health issues affecting children and ensuring transparency in pharmaceutical regulation.

Makary, a surgeon and researcher at Johns Hopkins University, has long advocated for cultural changes within the FDA. He expressed concerns about the ingredients used in school lunches, particularly seed oils and food dyes, which he believes could be contributing to health problems among children. Makary proposed piloting healthier school lunch programs in select districts, stating that current practices may be harming students' well-being. He argued that using taxpayer dollars for potentially harmful foods should be re-evaluated, especially when these foods contribute to childhood illnesses.

During the hearing, Makary also addressed the contentious issue of mifepristone, a medication used in medical abortions. He committed to forming an expert coalition to review data on the drug, emphasizing a thorough and unbiased examination. Makary stressed that any policy decisions would be based on scientific evidence and adherence to existing laws. He noted that while mifepristone has been approved for decades, ongoing data collection is essential to ensure its continued safety and efficacy.

The hearing also delved into the canceled meeting of the Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee (VRBPAC). Senators questioned Makary about this unexpected cancellation, which raised concerns about transparency. Makary assured the committee that if confirmed, he would re-evaluate the necessity of such meetings and ensure they proceed as needed. He acknowledged the importance of timely recommendations for flu vaccines and other critical public health measures.

Makary further highlighted the need to review the ethics policies governing FDA advisory committees. He voiced concerns about perceived conflicts of interest between industry and regulators, suggesting that stricter oversight might be necessary to maintain public trust. However, some VRBPAC members defended existing conflict-of-interest rules, asserting that they already prevent undue influence from pharmaceutical companies. Despite this, Makary remains committed to examining and potentially enhancing these policies.

Makary's nomination, along with those of Dr. Jay Bhattacharya for the National Institutes of Health and Dr. David Weldon for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, will face votes on March 13. If confirmed, Makary will report to Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the Secretary of Health and Human Services. His plans signal a potential shift in how the FDA addresses public health challenges, particularly concerning childhood nutrition and pharmaceutical regulations.